The Indian Journal of Law and Justice (IJLJ) is a peer-reviewed academic journal
published biannually in March and September by the Department of Law, University
of North Bengal, Darjeeling, West Bengal, India. The journal aims to promote high-
quality theoretical and empirical research on law, legal systems, and their interaction
with society across different periods and contexts.
Acceptable Use of AI in Research and Manuscript Preparation
The Indian Journal of Law and Justice (IJLJ) recognises the potential of generative
AI and AI-assisted technologies (“AI Tools”), when used responsibly, to help
researchers work efficiently, gain critical insights fast and achieve better outcomes.
Authors may use AI tools in a limited and responsible manner for the following
purposes:
- Language editing and grammar correction
- Formatting and structuring of manuscripts
Authors should consider the following as appropriate uses for GenAI in research
publishing that require disclosure within the methods or acknowledgements:
- Assistance with literature review or compilation of relevant sources
- Translation of materials as part of the research process
- Using software or code generated by AI to undertake additional research
- Assistance in research data visualisation
- Generation of representative illustrations or infographics
- Code enhanced or checked for errors by AI assistance
- Assistance with compilation of references
However, authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity
of the content in their manuscripts.
Prohibited Uses of AI
The following uses of AI are strictly prohibited:
- Generating substantial portions of academic text without proper disclosure.
- Fabricating legal citations, case references, statutes, or bibliographic sources.
- Creating false data, empirical findings, or legal interpretations.
- Using AI tools in a way that misrepresents authorship or intellectual contribution.
- Submitting AI-generated work as original human scholarship.
- Generation of incorrect text or content
- Generation of data or submission using a series of prompts
- Use of GenAI tools for editorial work or to conduct peer-review
Any such practices will be considered academic misconduct and may lead to
rejection of the manuscript or further institutional action.
Disclosure of AI Use
Authors shall mandatorily disclose any use of AI tools in manuscript preparation,
specifying the tool used, its purpose (e.g., grammar correction, summarisation), and
affirming that the intellectual content is their own.
Example Disclosure Statement:
“The author(s) used artificial intelligence tools (specify AI tools) solely for language
editing and formatting purposes. All intellectual content, analysis, and conclusions
presented in the manuscript are the responsibility of the author(s).”
Failure to disclose the use of AI tools may be treated as ethical misconduct and may
lead to rejection or retraction.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors submitting manuscripts to the Indian Journal of Law and Justice must
ensure that:
- Their work is original and within or below the permissible limit of 10(Ten)
percent in the similarity index as recognised by the UGC regulations (2018)
on Promotion of Academic Integrity.
- All sources are properly cited and acknowledged.
- Any AI assistance is appropriately disclosed.
- AI-generated content does not replace critical legal analysis and scholarly
interpretation.
Authors remain fully accountable for the content of their submissions, including
any part produced with the assistance of AI.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Peer reviewers are expected to:
- Evaluate manuscripts based on academic merit, originality, and scholarly
contribution.
- Identify possible AI-generated inconsistencies, fabricated references, or
unusual patterns in writing.
- Maintain confidentiality and refrain from uploading submitted manuscripts to
AI systems.
Compliance with Academic Ethics
This policy aligns with widely accepted international publishing ethics standards,
including those relating to:
- academic integrity
- plagiarism prevention
- responsible use of technology in research
Any violation of this policy may result in:
- rejection of the manuscript,
- retraction of published articles,